American Civil War Medicine & Surgical Antiques

Surgical Set collection from 1860 to 1865 - Civilian and Military

Civil War:  Medicine, Surgeon Education & Medical Textbooks

 Dr. Michael Echols  &  Dr. Doug Arbittier


 Home page  |   Feedback & Contact Dr. Echols  |  SEARCH this site   |  Article Indexes   |   Medical Faculty & Authors

 Civil War Medical Books  |  Medicine Containers   |   1800's & Civil War Surgery Set Displays

Medical College Index - Lecture Cards  |  Civil War Medical Book Author-Title Index


American Civil War Surgical Antiques

Research and Identification

Civil War Era Surgical Sets, Surgeon's Images

Civil War Surgeon Education & Medical Textbooks

Established 1995    .     Dr. Michael Echols Collection


As seen in:  Warman's Civil War Collectibles, Antique Week, Northeast Antiques, and various TV programs, Antiques & Collecting publications

Estate Tax Liability: The Fine Art of Determining Fair Market Value

The following is from Heritage Auctions ( on Fair Market Value (2009):

Estate Tax Liability: The Fine Art of Determining Fair Market Value Almost 250 sections of the Internal Revenue Code require stating something known as Fair Market Value (FMV), in order to determine tax liability. In the auction world, FMV is used to illuminate sage auction estimates for everything from Picassos to Pez dispensers. The term Fair Market Value however, and the concepts behind it often cause a great deal of confusion, prompting one U.S. tax court judge to lament: "Value, like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder."

Fair Market Value is a complex determination of value framed by the U.S. Federal government for tax liability assessment, be it estate tax, gift tax, or income tax. The good book when it comes to FMV is the U.S. government's tax regulation Sec. 20.2031-1(b). Many estate attorneys and appraisers can recite by heart the first part of this regulation: The Fair Market Value is price at which the property would change hands between a willing buyer and willing seller, neither under any compulsion to buy or sell... While this is certainly the right chapter, it is not the only verse, and it behooves us to look at the regulation in full. Failure to consider the totality of the FMV definition may lead to inaccurate valuations.

The regulation also states FMV is not to be determined by a forced sale price. So, while the U.S. government may consider the sales price reached for liquidated estate assets the most probative evidence of its FMV, the relevant regulation specifically recognizes an owner's right not to sell, due to the benefits attendant to retained ownership. Fair Market Value therefore can describe the value of property unsold. Without the actual sale price of subject property indicating FMV, appraisers typically rely on the Market Comparison Approach to arrive at values.

This appraisal method entails determining the FMV of an object by relating it to past retail sales results of items of similar qualities. Similar qualities for property may include: maker, size, age, materials, and subject matter. This method is problematic however when it comes to appraising hand-made antiques and fine art, due to the unique nature of such property. Determining appropriately diagnostic comparables for such unique objects is inherently subjective. Other factors such as provenance (ownership history) and vendor status, e.g. high-end gallery, are equally unscientific, yet may also impact value.

The sale of chosen comparables must also have occurred in a relevant marketplace, that is, where such property is generally obtained by the public in the retail market. The regulations cite a theoretical example of a used car having the FMV equal to what a used car with comparable qualities could cost the general public if purchased from a used car dealer (the typical market for such items). It is critical to note here that FMV is not determined by the amount that might be obtained from the sale of such a car, but rather from how much it would cost to purchase a comparable one.

Determining the appropriate marketplace for a piece of property occurs on a case by case basis, as no one marketplace necessarily qualifies a priori. Retail market transactions, which involve the ultimate consumer, occur at dealerships, stores, and auction houses. However, wholesale transactions may occur at all of these venues as well. Both layers of the marketplace may operate simultaneously, depending on the nature of the property, and the status of the buyer. What a jewelry dealer pays for a diamond from a jewel importer, could not be taken for the FMV of the same stone after it has been retailed to the general public. Or, to use an example one court chose, the FMV of a head of cattle sold at a cattle auction could not be used as the FMV of a cow's worth of steaks at the supermarket.

Finally, the market comparison approach is predicated upon sales of comparables with a reasonable length of time prior to the appraisal's effective date. Anticipation of future value is generally dismissed as unreliable and unknowable. FMV is only meaningful when tied to the effective date of the appraisal, as the market can fluctuate significantly due to changes in supply and demand, fad and fashion.

The determination of FMV is a complex process, best suited to auction house specialists and professional appraisers, who are actively in tune with the current marketplace. Even then experts can differ widely; ten appraisers looking at the same item might come up with ten different opinions of value, and arguably, all of them could be correct and defensible. There is no irrefutable right answer for Fair Market Value, but there are some recognized processes and standards that can be followed in striving to determine it.

The Appraisal Foundation, a not-for-profit organization authorized by Congress, was created in 1987 to support the appraisal profession by creating method standards and codes of ethics. These are published in the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP). Appraisal organizations, such as the American Society of Appraisers and the Appraises Association of America, require adhering to USPAP standards as a requirement for membership.

Following the complete FMV definition prescribed by the Treasury Department, and adhering to USPAP keeps the problematic process of FMV determination manageable.

The Art and Collectibles Capital Gains Tax Treatment Parity Act (S. 374) sponsored by Senator Pete Domenici (R-NM) and Charles Schumer (D-NY) would "provide the same capital gains treatment for art and collectibles as for other investment property." Currently the capital gains tax rate for art and collectibles is 28%, compared to 15% for other types of investments. As fine art and collectibles have emerged of late as a powerful alternative asset class, the Art Dealers Association of America and many auction houses support this legislation. Some fear, if the bill passes and the capital gains tax is lowered on sales of art and collectibles, donations to museums would diminish. The bill also includes language comparable to Leahy's regarding raising the write-off for artist donations to fair market value level.


Medical Antiques Index

American Civil War Medicine & Surgical Antiques Index

Contact Dr. Arbittier or Dr. Echols



Civil War Medical Collections 


Direct links to all medical & Civil War collections on this site                         

American Surgical Sets:

Pre-Civil War:  1 | 2  -   Post-Civil War:  3  -  Civil War 1861-1865:  4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8   INDEX

Medical Text-Books:

1 | 1a | 2 | 2a | 3 | 3a | 4 | 4a | 5 | 5a | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 9a | 10 | 11 | 12    INDEX

Surgeon General's Office Library printed catalogues: 1840 | 1864 | 1865
Medical Lecture Cards: 1 | 2 | 34 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21    INDEX

Medical Faculty and Authors:


Navy Surgeon Exams:

1863 Navy Surgeon Applicant Exams with Biographies   INDEX ONE | INDEX TWO

Surgeon CDVs, Images:

Army: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8    INDEX

Navy: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8   

Hosp Dep't Bottles, Tins, 

U.S. Army Pannier:

1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6

American Civil War Medicine & Surgical Antiques

Please request permission before commercial use or publication of any content or photos on this site and credit any use with:  "American Civil War Surgical Antiques"   All content and all original photography on this Web Site is copyrighted 1995 - 2015 and may not be used on any other web site or in commercial print without the expressed e-mail permission from Dr. Arbittier:  Contact   All rights reserved. 


Students doing reports or projects are welcome to use the content of this site without permission, but credits would be appreciated.


Please note: information on this site may not be normally referenced as this is an active and long-term educational research project.  Personal notes may not be properly cited for publication.  Various articles are digitally reproduced under the 'fair-use act' of the copyright laws and are intended for educational purposes only.  Many citations are from Google digital 'books' and can be traced backwards via a search of a unique string in the citation.


 Arbittier Museum of Medical History Tour:   1 | 2 | 3


Last update: Monday, December 12, 2016